advertisement
Doctor Shows for Dummies - by Robert Isenberg
House/FOX Watch What You Eat
Doctor shows are not for the weak of stomach -- especially now that special effects can replicate pretty much any kind of grisly surgery, from invasive biopsies to impromptu amputations. It was all fine and good when the "Chicago Hope" team had to cut open a guy's chest, but the "House" specialists are particularly fond of zooming in on dying blood cells and decaying bone marrow. You might want to hold off on that sloppy joe until after the credits have rolled.
ER/NBC

Don't Expect to Understand What's Going On
Nowadays, the only people as important as producers and writers
are the medical consultants who make doctor shows believable.
Because most TV watchers haven't been to medical school, it's
easy for the speeches about aortic arches and fibrodysplasia to
go right over their heads. But that's OK; it's just the show's way
of saying, "See, we totally know what we're talking about."
Fortunately, the technical stuff is the least important part of the show. Writers work hard to make sure that, no matter how little you may know about lymphoma, the important plot points are spoken in plain English.

M*A*S*H/CBS The Most Dangerous Medical Job Is the Leading Man
Once upon a time, there was a show called "Chicago Hope," starring a Broadway star named Mandy Patinkin. His show fought a bitter ratings battle with "ER," starring George Clooney. Despite some passionate performances, it didn't take too many surgeries for both these leading men to retire their latex gloves -- a doctor show tradition since "St. Elsewhere." The same goes for lesser actors, who, like real doctors, get juggled in and out of hospitals like so many hypodermic needles. These can be some of the most dependably tear-jerking moments on television -- watching a doctor you loved and trusted get the boot, or storm out in frustration, or, in the case of "M*A*S*H," have his helicopter shot down in the episode's last five minutes. If the promos look dim for your favorite M.D., consider stocking up on hankies. 
ER/NBC The Ante Will Get Upped
Doctor shows are infamous for upping the ante. When "ER" first aired, it concerned mostly realistic cases, realistic doctors and realistic relationship qualms. In its final seasons, the "ER" characters faced massive power outages, shootings, nine-year comas -- and when that isn't exciting enough, the show sends its characters to Third World countries, where disease and civil war have a chance to wreak havoc on TV's most gold-hearted Chicagoans. One more season and we might see Dr. Dubenko operating on an extraterrestrial. Or a whale. 
Doogie Howser, M.D./ABC There's Always a Moral
It's been a long time since Doogie Howser tapped at his computer, recounting those nuggets of wisdom he'd learned from the day's rounds. But just as actual medicine thrives on study and learning, doctor shows thrive on neatly packaged moral lessons. These might not be very profound (such as, "Don't lie about your condition," or, "There's no 'I' in team"), but we usually come away respecting caregivers just a little bit more -- even the ones who just play doctors on TV.
Robert Isenberg is a freelance writer, stage actor, comedian and playwright. Raised in Vermont, he discovered television -- as well as gas heat, electric stoves, e-mail and baklava -- when he moved to Pittsburgh, where he lives and performs.


Page 2 of 2      previous Previous