advertisement
Doctor Shows for Dummies - By Robert Isenberg

For a nation that works as hard as we do, spending 40 hours a week toiling in our respective cubicles, taxi cabs and warehouses, it's a wonder we spend so much time watching TV shows about people working. Whether it's an office comedy, a courtroom drama or a police procedural, Americans love to see people on the job. And nothing says "thankless stress" like the good old-fashioned doctor show. Today, the doctor show is more popular than
ever, with series such as "Grey's Anatomy" topping the prime-time ratings. And what

viewers don't like biting their nails during a daring surgery? Who doesn't enjoy a good

argument between two rival physicians over whether to pull the plug?

 

If you're still new to the doctor show and all things hospital, here's a simple,

straightforward guide to the world of televised caregiving. If there's a scalpel onscreen,

refer to these helpful hints for the medically malnourished.

House/FOX

Always Expect a Second Opinion
Early on in every doctor show, a physician will give a patient a diagnosis -- but don't trust it to save his or her life. "House" is like a mystery-thriller for the health-care profession; you start with one theory, and then House gradually works toward another, all the while snipping red tape and risking lives in his manic quest to redeem the Hippocratic oath. Yes, it looks like that patient is writhing around from heart palpitations, but don't be surprised if it ends up being some kind of obscure neurological seizure that only the most roguish, bureaucracy-battling doctor can treat.

Scrubs/NBC "Sex to the ER, Sex to the ER, Please"
Tongue-in-cheek shows such as "Green Wing" and "Scrubs" are basically high-budget soap operas, and whereas the surgical team still gets tangled up in doctoral dilemmas, it's just as likely to get tangled up in each other. The 1990s were a decade ruled by sexpot George Clooney, but now that he's migrated to Academy Award-land, he's been replaced by the lusty antics of Zach Braff and his self-absorbed colleagues. Don't find brain surgery sexy? TV doctors disagree. The high-tension confines of a busy ER have always been the perfect setting for relationship melodrama -- ever since the days of "General Hospital" and "Dr. Kildare" (yoy, that Richard Chamberlain got around). And as the seasons go by, partners trade off with astounding regularity. Now that's what we call rotations.
ER/NBC Never Trust the Patient
TV doctors can be flippant, aggressive and egotistical -- just like real doctors -- but the most suspicious character in the hospital is a patient going under the knife. Patients get caught lying about all kinds of things, from latent drug abuse to hidden pregnancy to drinking a glass of wine when the doctor specifically advised against it. This gets patients into nasty trouble, such as complicating an already daring operation or getting passed for a heart transplant. So, the patient quit smoking four months ago? The patient doesn't pop pills? The patient is fully insured? Don't believe it for a second.
ER/NBC Don't Watch a Doctor Show with an Actual Doctor
No matter how meticulous the research, no matter how convincing the jargon, doctor shows are not real life -- and your cardiologist friend will be the first to say so. Sure, you may hear about a condition such as Korsakov's syndrome or Munchausen disorder by proxy, and you'll feel like you learned something new, but the second you see physicians swarm into the operating room, your expert friend starts giving you an earful of complaint: "That's not at all how to use a defibrillator," or "Asthmatics don't wheeze like that." The only thing more obnoxious is watching a courtroom drama with an actual lawyer.
Page 1 of 2          Next next